In episode four, the Prince (Freddie Stroma) proves his love to Daphne with an elaborate diamond necklace — a gift so expensive that her mother even suggests she not wear it out to the ball.

Later, when Daphne storms off the dance floor as the Prince is about to propose, she tears it off her neck and leaves it on a bridge, never to be seen or spoken of again.

Eagle-eyed fans quickly spotted the costume blunder, and shared their theories as to what happened to it on Twitter.

LIAM DANIEL/NETFLIX

Freddie Stroma Bridgerton

“Quick Bridgerton question: Daphne left the Prince’s necklace on a bridge & no one ever mentioned it again?? Did some lucky cater waiter cash it in and make a run to Italy?“New Yorkerwriter Emily Nussbaumasked.

In PEOPLE’s exclusive sneak peek at theBridgertoncast’s upcoming appearance onThe Netflix Afterparty,those fan questions are finally answered.

GREG GAYNE/NETFLIX

FORTUNE FEIMSTER, LONDON HUGHES, DAVID SPADE, GOLDA ROSHEUVEL, NICOLA COUGHLAN, PHOEBE DYNEVOR, and JONATHAN BAILEY in episode 102 of THE NETFLIX AFTERPARTY

“What happened to the Prince’s necklace that Daphne left in the garden?” asks comedian London Hughes, who cohostsNetflix AfterpartyalongsideDavid SpadeandFortune Feimster.

“There’s a theory that Cressida Cowper took it — sold it on the black market, who knows — but what really happened? Do you know what happened?” she continues, directing the question to Dynevor.

“I don’t know what happened, and I never flagged this on the day. I just I don’t know what I was thinking,” Dynevor replies, though she takes a liking to the fan theory about Cressida.

“Maybe Cressida Cowper has it — she’s stolen it,” the actress adds.

TheBridgertoncast joinsThe Netflix Afterpartyon Saturday, Jan. 23.

source: people.com